The Debate Topic about whether the Internet is Killing our Culture:
Well firstly this was discussed between Andrew Keen and Emily Bell. Andrew Keen started by asking three questions. The first question was “Is the internet good or bad for consumers of culture (the audience)?” Next was, “Is the internet good or bad for creators of culture (writers, film makers, musicians, journalists)?” Finally,” Is the internet good or bad for the cultural economy?” (The Guardian, 2007).
Well the debate refers to how dependent people have become when it comes to the internet. People use and sometimes need to use the internet everyday all day. This is for a variety of reasons, one is their job requires a computer and they need to be on the internet all the time while they are at work. So take the example, that if the internet was to breakdown for a few days meaning nobody could access it from anywhere at all. This would lead to chaos across the country and some people would not no what to do as the internet has always accessible to everybody all the time.
To get back to the questions, I believe the first question is good and bad for the consumers. It gives information to the consumers they need and is available fairly quickly. On the other hand though, it makes the consumers to reliant on it and they stop using other areas to find information out like in books which can be more reliable as some websites on the internet as well. Keen believes firmly that it is bad for the consumers (The Guardian, 2007). When it comes to the second question I believe that it is more bad than good for the writers, film makers, musicians and journalists, in the sense that music is downloaded illegally and they don not get paid fairly enough for what they are offering on the internet. However, they do get more publicity and their work is at least accessed and viewed more than if it was not on the internet. This is similar to Keen’s views on this question. The last question I would have to say that the internet is not great for the cultural economy a view shared by Keen also.
Saying all of these though, how many of us would say that they do not want to have access to the internet on a daily basis? The answer is maybe a handful of people at the most but more probable nobody would say this. In the long run, so to speak, it may well be killing our culture but it also could just simply be creating another culture! After looking at this debate carefully I believe that it is just changing our culture as we once new to something that is technology dependent but at the same time realising that we should not become to reliant on it.
Bibliography:
• Bell, E and Keen, A. (2007) Andrew Keen v Emily Bell: Is Today’s Internet Killing Our Culture? The Guardian (Comment is Free) (WWW) available from: http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2007/aug/10/andrewkeenvemilybell
Copyrights and wrongs
16 years ago
